The Real Story Behind Paganism History: Separating Myths from Facts

The history of paganism is rich and diverse, and around you more than you may know. Did you know there are over 750,000 Wiccans in the United States alone? That’s right – paganism has grown from ancient roots to become America’s fifth-largest religion. But the real story of paganism starts somewhere quite different from what most people imagine today.

The term “pagan” first appeared around the 4th century when Christians needed a word for folks who didn’t worship the God of Abraham. They chose the Latin word “pagani,” which simply meant “people of the place” or country dwellers. Not exactly a compliment back then. Fast forward to modern times, and this spiritual path has completely transformed itself. Current estimates put the number of Neo-Pagans in the US between 150,000 to 1.2 million – quite a range, but impressive either way.

I’ve spent years researching religious traditions, and what fascinates me most about paganism is how it evolved from a negative label into something many people proudly identify with today. This article cuts through the myths and misconceptions to show you the real historical journey. We’ll explore how this nature-focused spiritual movement grew to include everything from Celtic practices to Greco-Roman traditions and even elements of Native American spirituality.

The Ancient Roots of Paganism

The roots of paganism run deeper than most people realize, stretching back to humanity’s earliest spiritual expressions. When I look at archeological evidence, it’s clear our ancestors weren’t primitive in their beliefs at all – they developed sophisticated spiritual systems centered around their connection to the natural world. These early beliefs eventually evolved into the complex polytheistic traditions that dominated human spirituality for thousands of years.

Early nature worship and animism

Nature worship stands as one of our earliest spiritual frameworks. People across ancient continents venerated natural phenomena they couldn’t control but absolutely depended on for survival. This veneration, sometimes called naturism or physiolatry, focused on worshipping nature deities believed to control everything from weather patterns to agricultural fertility.

At its heart was animism—the belief that every object, animate or inanimate, possessed thoughts, feelings, and the ability to communicate with people. Unlike the hierarchical religions we’re familiar with today, these animistic worldviews had no walls between humans and the natural world. For early foraging societies, this meant:

• All beings existed in spiritual equality, with humans holding no special status
• Natural elements like rocks, rivers, and trees possessed consciousness
• Spiritual practices required consideration of all beings’ feelings and desires

What’s fascinating is how indigenous peoples across numerous regions viewed natural phenomena—stars, rain, animals—as forces worthy of spiritual respect. They didn’t worship nature as some all-powerful entity; instead, they recognized specific powers within individual natural elements. These powers had different names depending on where you were: “mana” in Polynesia, “orenda” among the Iroquois, and “wakanda” for the Sioux.

The key concept running through these beliefs was the recognition of spiritual essence within everything—what anthropologists later termed “impersonal power” or “supernatural power”. This meant spiritual practices focused on maintaining harmony with these forces rather than trying to dominate them.

Pre-agricultural spiritual practices

Before agriculture came along, hunter-gatherer societies weren’t just focused on survival – they developed complex spiritual frameworks. Based on archaeological findings, we can say with certainty that religious thinking emerged in the Upper Paleolithic around 50,000 years ago, though some scholars think it might have started even earlier.

One thing I find particularly interesting is that prehistoric religion appears to have been polytheistic, worshipping multiple deities. The archaeological evidence suggests religious concepts predate monotheism in recorded history. The oldest burials showing belief in an afterlife date back to between 50,000 and 30,000 BCE.

Perhaps the most eye-opening evidence challenging what we thought we knew about religion’s development comes from Göbekli Tepe in modern-day Turkey. This massive religious complex, built around 9600 BCE, is at least 1,000 years older than agriculture in that region. This turns conventional wisdom on its head – spiritual organization may have preceded and possibly even motivated agricultural development, not the other way around as previously assumed.

Building Göbekli Tepe required hundreds of workers coordinating their efforts, suggesting the supporting society numbered in the thousands at minimum. This shows that complex social organization and religious expression didn’t need agriculture as a foundation.

Development of polytheistic systems

As humans shifted from hunter-gatherer bands to agricultural communities, their religious frameworks changed dramatically. Before farming, animistic belief systems viewed humans as equals with other animals and natural elements. Once people started farming, this relationship transformed completely—sheep and grains became possessions rather than spiritual equals.

This created a real theological problem: humans needed new spiritual entities to mediate their relationship with the natural world they now wanted to control. Gods emerged as the solution, serving as intermediaries between humans and nature in exchange for worship.

Eventually, polytheistic systems popped up throughout the ancient world. These frameworks featured hierarchically organized pantheons that mirrored the increasingly complex social structures of early civilizations. As empires expanded and trade networks grew, local deities gave way to more comprehensive pantheons addressing the needs of an interconnected world.

We have well-documented polytheistic traditions from across the ancient world, including Sumerian, Egyptian, Greek, Roman, Norse, Yoruba, and Aztec pantheons. These divine hierarchies typically reflected the social order of their respective civilizations, with gods assigned specific domains that matched human divisions of labor.

Despite the rise of polytheism, animistic elements hung around within these more structured religious systems. Many polytheistic cultures maintained beliefs in additional supernatural entities beyond their primary deities, including demonic forces, ancestral spirits, and nature beings.

Classical Paganism in Greece and Rome

_{Image Source: TheCollector}

When it comes to ancient religious practices, nothing beats classical paganism in Greece and Rome for documentation and influence. These weren’t simple belief systems – they were sophisticated polytheistic religions that shaped every aspect of Mediterranean life for over a thousand years. The fingerprints of these traditions are still all over Western civilization today.

Olympian gods and civic religion

Both Greek and Roman religions centered around clearly defined human-like deities who people worshiped through prayer, animal sacrifice, and elaborate festivals. The Greeks had their twelve Olympian gods, believed to live atop Mount Olympus, the tallest mountain in mainland Greece.

Zeus ran the show as sky god and father of the gods, with his wife Hera serving as queen. The rest of the gang included Poseidon (sea), Athena (wisdom and warfare), Apollo (music and prophecy), Artemis (hunting), Hermes (messenger), Aphrodite (love), Ares (war), Hephaistos (metalworking), plus Demeter and Dionysos. What I find particularly interesting is that these gods weren’t exactly moral examples – they had human vices and often behaved worse than the people worshiping them!

Religion wasn’t some separate part of life – it was woven right into civic existence. Every Greek city-state had its own patron deity that unified its citizens. Athens had Athena, who they typically showed in full armor with her shield and helmet.

The calendar year was packed with religious festivals. The four most famous ones – held at Olympia, Delphi, Nemea, and Isthmia – drew participants from all over the Greek-speaking world. These Panhellenic celebrations featured everything from processions and athletic competitions to sacrifices, helping strengthen cultural bonds between communities that might otherwise have little in common.

For everyday folks, religion touched literally everything. Homes had household shrines, neighborhoods had their sacred spots, and the calendar organized life around religious observances. I’ve always thought the relationship between humans and gods back then was fascinatingly practical – gods were expected to deliver benefits, while humans offered sacrifices and gifts as thanks. Simple. Straightforward. No complex theology needed.

Mystery cults and their practices

Alongside the public religion existed something more secretive – the mystery cults. These religious schools only allowed participation from initiates (called mystai) and kept their rituals and practices under tight wraps.

The most famous were the Eleusinian Mysteries, which were ancient even by ancient Greek standards, predating the Greek Dark Ages. These ceremonies told the story of Demeter and Persephone, promising initiates secret knowledge about getting a better afterlife. Then there were the Bacchic Mysteries centered on Dionysus (or Bacchus to the Romans), which involved ecstatic ceremonies and wild dancing. I can only imagine what these gatherings were actually like!

Mystery cults generally shared a few key features:

• An initiation process for members to join
• Secret rituals and practices
• Promises of salvation or improved afterlife

The big draw of these mystery cults was that they offered something public religion didn’t – personal religious experience and hope for salvation after death. During the Roman period, these mystery traditions really took off, with foreign cults like Egyptian Isis, Persian Mithras, and Phrygian Cybele becoming popular throughout the empire. The Mithraic mysteries were particularly interesting in how they organized their feasts – initiates would recline on stone benches along the sides of their worship space, typically fitting between 15 to 30 diners, rarely more than 40.

Philosophical approaches to traditional deities

Greek philosophy developed right alongside religious practice, creating a fascinating interplay between the two. Unlike today where we separate religion and philosophy, ancient thinkers regularly tackled theological questions while exploring nature and ethics.

Different philosophers approached traditional religious beliefs in various ways. Plato took myths and reinterpreted them as allegories containing deeper truths. Others questioned whether gods should be thought of in human form at all. The Stoics wove divine principles into their understanding of natural law and cosmic order.

Throughout this period, you couldn’t really separate religious and philosophical thought. Many philosophers doubled as priests or regularly participated in religious festivals. Even skeptics like Cicero, who served as an augur (a religious official), recognized religion’s value for maintaining social order. This philosophical engagement with religion produced sophisticated theological concepts that later influenced both Christianity and modern Western thought.

The Romans approached religion a bit differently than the Greeks. They basically adopted the Greek gods but gave them new names while keeping their functions – Zeus became Jupiter, Hera became Juno, and Athena became Minerva. Roman religion was super practical, focusing more on performing rituals correctly than engaging in deep theological speculation. For Romans, it was all about maintaining the proper relationship with the gods through the right actions – the pax deorum or “peace of the gods” as they called it.

How Christianity Defined Paganism

The relationship between Christianity and older religious traditions is one of the most consequential religious shifts in history. As Christianity grew from a persecuted minority faith to become the dominant religion of the Roman Empire, it completely redefined how people understood pre-Christian religions – creating definitions that would stick around for centuries.

Origin of the term ‘pagan’

The word “pagan” itself tells us a lot about early Christian attitudes toward non-Christians. Originally, the Latin term paganus just meant “villager,” “rustic,” or “civilian” with no religious meaning at all. It came from pāgus, which referred to a small unit of land in a rural district. Think of it as somewhat insulting – similar to calling someone a “hick” or “country bumpkin”.

It wasn’t until Christianity’s rise that paganus took on religious significance. By the fourth century CE, Christians started using it for anyone who didn’t worship the monotheistic God of Abraham, Judaism, and Islam. Throughout Late Antiquity, Christians slapped this label on followers of various religions from both Antiquity and the Middle Ages, including:

• Greco-Roman polytheistic traditions
• Mystery religions and philosophical systems like Neoplatonism
• Local ethnic religions both inside and outside the empire

From the early Christians’ perspective, all these diverse religions qualified as “ethnic” or “gentile” (ethnikos, gentilis), terms translating goyim, which eventually became paganus. This created a clear “us versus them” division that would shape religious conversations for centuries to come.

Christian writers and their portrayal of non-Christians

Early Christian apologists didn’t just disagree with non-Christian practices – they crafted specific narratives about them. Instead of seeing paganism as a coherent religious system, they painted it as a mishmash of misguided beliefs. What’s more, Christian writers often described these traditions as literally demonic.

By the early second century, Romans no longer saw Christians as just another Jewish sect but as one of many foreign cults popping up throughout the empire. Christians became noticeable by their absence from festival activities where ritual sacrifices happened – behavior that Romans viewed as both sacrilegious and treasonous.

When defending their faith, Christian authors consistently portrayed pagan worship as focused on “lifeless works of art” rather than true divinity. I’ve always found St. Athanasius’s critique particularly telling – he criticized pagans for worshiping “the carver’s art” instead of actual gods. This negative portrayal served both theological and political purposes, drawing a bright line between Christian truth and pagan error.

St. Justin Martyr didn’t pull any punches when he declared Christians “atheists” regarding pagan deities: “We do indeed proclaim ourselves atheists in respect to those whom you call gods, but not in regard to the Most True God”. His writings further distanced Christians from pagan practices: “We do not reverence the same gods as you do, nor offer to the dead libations and the savor of fat, and crowns for their statues, and sacrifices”.

Political aspects of religious conversion

Religious conversion throughout the Roman Empire became increasingly political after Constantine’s conversion (traditionally dated to 312 CE). During this period, Christians believed Constantine’s conversion showed Christianity had already triumphed over paganism “in Heaven,” making further action against pagans unnecessary from their perspective.

After decades of persecution, Christianity’s legalization through the Edict of Milan (313 CE) completely transformed the religious landscape. The faith gained governmental privileges, including tax exemptions for clergy. Constantine himself was somewhat inconsistent – destroying some temples, converting others to churches, and grabbing temple funds to finance his own projects.

Emperor Gratian took much more decisive anti-pagan action, redirecting financial subsidies from Rome’s traditional cults to the crown’s coffers, seizing the income of pagan priests, forbidding their right to inherit land, and refusing to accept the title of Pontifex Maximus.

The final transition came under Theodosius I, who declared Nicene Christianity the empire’s official religion. But Theodosius wasn’t stupid – he took care not to alienate the empire’s still substantial pagan population, appointing moderate pagans to important administrative posts and winning over the influential pagan lobby in the Roman Senate.

What many people don’t realize is that harsh imperial edicts often ran into passive resistance from governors and magistrates, which limited their actual impact. By the Early Middle Ages (800-1000 CE), faiths labeled as pagan had mostly disappeared in the West through a mix of peaceful conversion, natural religious evolution, persecution, and military conquest.

Survival of Pagan Practices in Folk Traditions

Despite Christianity’s official triumph, pagan practices didn’t just disappear overnight. Instead, they found a hiding place in folk traditions where they continued to thrive for centuries. Throughout Europe and beyond, ancient beliefs mixed with Christian teachings, creating rich combined traditions that preserved elements of paganism while adapting to new religious frameworks.

Agricultural festivals and their transformation

Some of the most obvious survivors of paganism are seasonal celebrations tied to agricultural cycles. The clever thing that happened was how many popular indigenous festivals and holy days were skillfully repackaged for Christianity, with goddess and god figures gradually morphing into Christian saints. The best example of this Christian-pagan blending has to be how Hellenistic Isis imagery influenced Catholic Mary veneration—just look at images of Mary with baby Jesus and you’ll see they still look remarkably like Isis holding baby Horus.

What amazes me is how consistently these seasonal celebrations continued through the centuries:

• Samhain (October 31/November 1) became All Saints’ Day and All Souls’ Day
• Winter solstice celebrations got connected to Christmas
• Spring fertility festivals merged with Easter traditions
• Summer solstice fires were reimagined as St. John’s Day celebrations

In rural areas especially, where folks maintained stronger connections to ancestral practices, pre-Christian belief systems kept informing celebrations even as their outward appearance changed. I’ve noticed in my research that communities held onto agricultural rituals for prosperity right alongside their Christian practices, showing just how deeply these beliefs were embedded in rural life.

Folk magic and healing practices

Just like festivals transformed rather than disappeared, healing traditions and folk magic stuck around in communities that were Christian in name. In Appalachia, where I’ve spent time studying local traditions, folk magic practices called “root work,” “granny magic,” or “kitchen witchery” developed by blending Native American plant knowledge with European folk traditions. These practices emerged when Scottish, Irish, and English settlers mixed their traditional healing methods with indigenous wisdom about local plants.

“Granny witches” weren’t what most people think of as witches today – they were midwives, healers, and keepers of ancestral knowledge who provided medical care to remote communities that often didn’t trust doctors. Between 1860 and 1980, Appalachian women maintained comprehensive knowledge about herbal remedies for everything from stomach problems to burns.

The thing most folks don’t realize is that most practitioners of folk magic worked within Christian frameworks, not against them. Many used the book of Psalms “like a spell book,” combined with deep knowledge of the land. For certain treatments, like burn healing, effectiveness supposedly depended on the burned person’s faith, with traditions specifically saying that no fee should be charged because it was “the work of the Lord”.

Sacred sites and their continued use

The most compelling evidence of paganism’s staying power might be how sacred sites remained venerated. British people kept their reverence for the same sacred locations through repeated conquests, conversions, and relocations. At various transition points, including during conversion to Christianity, people deliberately reused ancient pagan sites and buildings.

Across numerous European regions, certain natural spots—hills, impressive trees, springs, rivers, and especially places where waters joined—kept their spiritual significance across religious changes. The Celts saw these sites as meeting places between the physical and supernatural worlds, with water serving as a pathway to the Otherworld.

Excavations at sites like Sutton in Britain show continuous religious use from the late Neolithic period through the Bronze Age, Iron Age, Roman era, Anglo-Saxon period, and into modern times—that’s at least four thousand years of unbroken spiritual significance. This kind of continuity shows just how deeply rooted sacred geography remained in people’s consciousness, outlasting major theological shifts. It’s pretty mind-blowing when you think about it – the same spot being considered holy for four millennia, regardless of which gods were officially in fashion!

The Romantic Revival and Scholarly Interest

The Romantic era of the 18th and 19th centuries kicked off something pretty amazing – a renewed fascination with ancient pagan traditions that would eventually lead to modern paganism. This wasn’t just some academic curiosity; it was a full-blown intellectual awakening that completely changed how we understand pre-Christian beliefs.

19th century nationalism and folklore collection

When nationalism swept across Europe, scholars suddenly got really interested in their cultural heritage. Thinkers like Johann Gottfried Herder (1744-1803) and Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814) played huge roles in this revival. Their ideas showed up right when people were getting fed up with industrial modernization and yearning for something more authentic and connected to their national identity.

What I find fascinating about this period is the systematic collection of folklore that preserved elements of paganism history. The Brothers Grimm in Germany weren’t just collecting cute fairy tales – they were documenting cultural memory. Same with Elias Lönnrot and his work on the Kalevala in Finland, and Alexander Afanasyev in Russia. When you look closely at these collections, you can spot pre-Christian elements that had somehow survived centuries of Christian dominance.

Across Europe, emerging nation-states were desperate to establish their unique identities. What better way than connecting to heroic pasts that predated Christianity? During the revolutionary period of 1848, national epics popped up all over the place, and many of them incorporated pagan themes. It’s like these new nations were saying, “Hey, our identity goes way deeper than just the last thousand years of Christianity.”

Academic study of pre-Christian religions

The scholarly study of paganism didn’t happen overnight. It took a long time before it became a legitimate academic field. I consider Ronald Hutton’s book The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles (1991) a real game-changer – finally, someone was offering serious historical analysis of pre-Christian traditions instead of just repeating myths and assumptions.

Academic interest really picked up steam in the 1990s. The first formal academic conference on modern paganism happened at Newcastle University in 1993, followed by a bigger gathering at Lancaster University in 1996. Then peer-reviewed scholarship started to flourish with journals like The Pomegranate beginning publication in 2004. Before this period, anyone studying paganism seriously was often seen as a bit fringe – but these developments helped legitimize the field.

Literary and artistic reimagining of pagan themes

The Romantic poets weren’t just dabbling in pagan themes – they were actively reimagining paganism for a modern audience. Percy Shelley and John Keats dove deep into these themes in their works. When Shelley died in 1822, his friends actually conducted what’s believed to be the first pagan funeral in Italy since Rome converted to Christianity. That’s pretty remarkable when you think about it!

This artistic fascination didn’t stop with the early Romantics. Later figures like George Meredith and Algernon Swinburne wrote about ancient goddesses, and Oscar Wilde even summoned Pan to Victorian London in his poetry. By 1890, things had progressed to the point where organizations like the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn were offering Londoners the chance to participate in rituals that venerated Jesus alongside Egyptian and Greek deities. Talk about spiritual buffet!

What strikes me most about this period is how it built a bridge between ancient paganism and modern practice. Without these Romantic-era thinkers, artists, and scholars, the modern pagan revival might never have happened. They dusted off these old traditions and made them relevant again for a world that had seemingly moved on.

Modern Paganism: New Religions with Ancient Inspiration

_{Image Source: American Marriage Ministries}

The mid-20th century brought something truly remarkable – a revival of ancient spiritual traditions reimagined for modern life. This completely transformed the landscape of alternative religions. What fascinates me most about this period is how these ancient beliefs were reworked for contemporary practice while still honoring their historical roots.

Gardner, Wicca, and the birth of Neo-Paganism

Gerald Brosseau Gardner, who many call “the Father of Wicca,” fundamentally changed modern paganism when he went public with his coven after England repealed its witchcraft laws in the early 1950s. Gardner claimed he’d been initiated into the New Forest coven back in 1939, and believed he had discovered a surviving pre-Christian witch cult. But here’s where it gets interesting – research by scholars like Hutton and Heselton later showed this coven probably only formed in the mid-1930s based on Margaret Murray’s theories, which have since been discredited.

What Gardner actually did was blend practices from this New Forest coven with ceremonial magic, Kabbalah, and writings from Aleister Crowley to create what we now call Gardnerian Wicca. After initiating several High Priestesses, including Doreen Valiente, his tradition spread throughout Britain and eventually made its way to Australia and the United States by the late 1950s. The speed at which it spread shows just how hungry people were for these kinds of spiritual alternatives.

Reconstructionist movements and historical accuracy

While Wicca took a more mix-and-match approach, a different movement called polytheistic reconstructionism emerged in the late 1960s and really picked up steam in the 1990s. These folks took a much more scholarly approach, attempting to faithfully revive pre-Christian religions through rigorous historical research across multiple disciplines like archeology, folklore studies, and anthropology.

Reconstructionists are pretty serious about distinguishing themselves from more blended traditions. They focus on:

• Avoiding attempts to create a one-size-fits-all pan-European paganism
• Following established research guidelines
• Using multi-disciplinary approaches
• Recreating cultural contexts to better understand religious beliefs

I’ve met reconstructionists who can talk for hours about the minute details of ancient religious practices. Their dedication to accuracy is impressive, even if it sometimes makes for less accessible spiritual paths than Wicca’s more flexible approach.

Contemporary pagan diversity and practice

When you look at today’s pagan landscape, the diversity is absolutely mind-boggling. Modern paganism exists on a spectrum from strict reconstructionist approaches seeking historical accuracy to eclectic movements that freely mix elements from various traditions. The theological views are just as diverse – spanning from polytheism and animism all the way to atheism. Some practitioners see deities as literal beings while others view them as psychological archetypes or symbols.

To push back against discrimination, organizations like the Pagan Federation (founded 1971) and the European Congress of Ethnic Religions formed, creating a sense of collective pagan identity. Despite all their differences, this diverse community shares one common thread – they all draw inspiration from pre-Christian religions of Europe, North Africa, and West Asia while adapting them for modern life.

What surprises many people is just how mainstream some of these practices have become. I remember when mentioning you were pagan would get you strange looks or worse. Now it’s not uncommon to find open pagans in professional settings, government positions, and everyday life. The journey from hidden covens to public acceptance hasn’t been straightforward, but it’s certainly been remarkable.

Conclusion about the history of paganism

Looking at paganism’s journey through history, I’m struck by its remarkable story of adaptation and resilience. Early Christians used “pagan” as an insult, but these ancient spiritual traditions proved stubborn. They survived through folk practices, seasonal celebrations, and sacred sites. Instead of vanishing, pagan beliefs simply transformed, blending with new religious frameworks while holding onto their core elements of nature reverence and polytheistic worship.

Modern paganism stands as living proof of this adaptability. Isn’t it fascinating how something supposedly stamped out centuries ago continues to thrive today? The scholarly interest during the Romantic period laid the groundwork for contemporary revival, while figures like Gerald Gardner sparked new interpretations of ancient practices. Today’s practitioners run the gamut from strict reconstructionists with their noses in archaeology journals to eclectic types who blend multiple traditions as freely as a cocktail mixer.

I’ve spent years reading about these traditions, and what strikes me most is how understanding paganism’s history helps dispel common misconceptions. Many people still think of paganism as primitive or simplistic, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. Archaeological evidence, classical sources, and folk customs paint a picture of sophisticated belief systems that shaped human spirituality for millennia. These weren’t just simple nature worshippers – they created complex theological frameworks that influenced everything from agriculture to politics.

The persistence of these traditions despite centuries of active suppression makes me wonder – what other aspects of human spirituality have we underestimated or misunderstood? Examining these ancient roots provides valuable insights into both historical religious practice and contemporary spiritual movements. Plus, it reminds us that spiritual traditions, like the people who practice them, are remarkably adaptable when they need to be.

Simple. The history of paganism shows, paganism didn’t die – it evolved.